| |||
| Player | School | Year | Position |
| Drew Kunda | Keuka College | SR | Attack |
| Joe Glieco | Medaille College | SO | Attack |
| Andrew Abbott | SUNY Cobleskill | SR | Attack |
| TJ Radka | Keuka College | SR | Midfield |
| David Bennett | Medaille College | SR | Midfield |
| TJ Shaw | Cazenovia College | FR | Midfield |
| Greg Marsh | Keuka College | SR | Defense |
| Isaac Zehr | Keuka College | SR | Defense |
| Joe Dishaw | Medaille College | JR | Defense |
| Brett Leonard | Keuka College | SO | Goalkeeper |
| |||
| Player | School | Year | Position |
| Kyle Boland | Cazenovia College | SO | Attack |
| Jim Luthart | Medaille College | SO | Attack |
| Chris Sullivan | Keuka College | SR | Attack |
| Gareth Fabian | Cazenovia College | JR | Midfield |
| Chris Lamb | Cazenovia College | SR | Midfield |
| Kevin MacNeill | SUNY Cobleskill | SO | Midfield |
| Pete Davis | Cazenovia College | JR | Defense |
| Gary Reisman | Cazenovia College | JR | Defense |
| Cody List | Keuka College | SR | Defense |
| Ben Dlugosh | Medaille College | SR | Goalkeeper |
